Show HN: Real Resume Examples from 1000s of Top Paid Professionals
visualcv.com
visualcv.com
I simply had deja vu when I saw this post (again) today, and wondered where I saw it. Searching HN showed nothing, which surprised me because I was certain I saw it here. The parent's link to the flag-killed post gave me an answer.
It is also technically a duplicate (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8577800) but we'll give you the benefit of the doubt on that.
To me it signals that you don't know what matters -- like using a plastic-binder on a school report.
If you could somehow use the design to communicate the content better -- then I'd be impressed.
EDIT: I just realized that this site builds the resumes. Again, they look nice, but other than that, I think they don't work any better as a resume than a plain one. In general I like well-designed marketing collateral, but resumes are things to skim and understand quickly -- I'd like to see good designs that accomplish that.
I can see at a glance that he has experience with frontend developent, clean code and agile development, can quickly see some keywords detailing that and if I'm hooked by that I can then read all that text about his work history.
Ratings. Ugh.
Also, is it really normal for people to list something like "clean code" as a skill at all? Let alone one that can be rated out-of-ten? It seems like putting "contains no cyanide" on breakfast cereal.
(it does look very nice, though—I may, um, "borrow" some of that design)
With respect to "clean code", this resume lists specific skills that fall under that umbrella. "TDD", "BDD", "CI".
My concern isn't for the interviewer, mind you, it's for the interviewee. Including a 10-scale is just asking to have to defend it. "What sorts of things might a person rated at a three on this scale know or be able to do? What would be different for a four? What makes you a 9 instead of an 8?" These questions suck. No way I'd want to open myself up to that, and IMO they're legitimate questions. You chose a 10-scale to represent your skills. No one made you do that. And you rated your front-end skills highly! Can I expect similar things from your level-9 "clean code"? If I ask you to put a bar graph on a page will you zoom it to an inappropriate scale or label an axis with values finer than we can even measure? That's the kind of impression I'd fear giving the interviewer.
However given this site is called "VisualCV" (emphasis on visual), I can see why people posting on there would want to include photos, in addition to the nice graphics and stuff.
Same goes for age. In UK you don't need to put your age on the CV since law says you can't be discrimined by how old (or young) you are. But again, here in Italy is a very common practice.
Photos are also problematic, in so far as they allow the person screening the resumes to make hiring decisions -- even subconscious decisions -- on the basis of race, gender, ethnicity, apparent age, or even just physical appearance. I imagine that requiring photos of all candidates would be illegal, or at least highly actionable, in the US.
That being said, I don't think there are any rules against putting a photo in one's resume here. I'd just do it with extreme caution. I only see significant upside if you are a great looking person, or have a photo that just screams "Now THAT is a kick-ass professional!" Otherwise, there is just too much risk involved. Risk that you'll be weeded out for "fit" (read: "This person doesn't look like the kind of person who works here"), or for having a weird photo, or even for being the kind of person weird enough to include a photo (since again, photos are not the norm in the US).
I will say this much: as unorthodox as these visual resumes are, I kind of like them. They stand out, and they present the vital information in a much more digestible format than ye olde paper resume does. I just think the photo aspect is tricky. I'd also wonder whether real-life HR managers, recruiters, and hiring managers would grok this style, or whether they'd find it too eccentric. Recruiters are usually working within a mold, not trying to break one.
I know when I worked at big companies, by the time I saw a resume it had always been through at least one system, and often two or three; and any formatting that the applicant had done was long stripped out, leaving bizarre line breaks and other problems all over the place.
For anyone applying to where I work please please please do not include a photo because I instantly know your age & ethnicity - things that I am not supposed to know about you.
Obviously I am going to see your face eventually (assuming you get to an on-site interview), but seeing it all before I get to talk to you in person can lead unconscious bias which is not good for anyone.
A bias has to be in favour of some people. Those people are usually the ones who include their photos.
With most job applications now demanding you fill out proprietary forms, I usually have to cut and paste into the fields supplied. I also have a simple pdf version with very minor formatting in case I am handing/emailing the resume to a contact.
That being said, this is a cool site, and it is probably useful for people working in artistic fields. Just remember that the content is the important part.
Same goes for business plans, marketing plans, all the various plans and paperwork you need when applying for loans, grants and such.
There's probably some benefit to be had in an 'examples or paperwork' site.
lawyer pay a lot of money to access samples of all sorts of letters, affidavits, submissions, petitions and whatnot. They're useful.
On the other hand, if you're a just-ship-it no-nonsense individual who likes to focus more on doing things than maintaining relationships, than by all means build that weird personal site that's nothing like a normal resume and that showcases all your relevant skills instead of using buzzwords. Companies with large and rigid internal social structures will probably avoid you, while volatile newer companies will seek you out.
Our goal for the project is to focus on how to present professional information visually and with UX techniques that we've learned from web development. To us, most resumes are stuffed with a lot of insubstantial text. We wanted to instantly see numbers, results and achievements in a glance. Recruiters generally take a few seconds to screen for key information and indicators of success and we wanted to present all those info with nice visual hierarchy and make it a pleasure to view. Admittedly, I don't think our current designs have hit those targets as well as I've hoped but we do have some exciting designs in the pipeline.
As you browse through the database you might notice that some of the resumes look a bit messy (they are the black on white design with sidebar images). These are mostly legacy users that we had to migrate to our new platform. Their previous resumes looked something like this: http://legacy.visualcv.com/
A resume should be just a clear and simple representation of you. Fancy does not always mean better.