That's a weird conclusion. Let's say I value the mug at $5. Obviously I'm not going to sell it for $5, because the transaction itself is an effort, so I would lose! The opposite for buying, obviously I'm not going to buy a mug for $5 if I think it's worth exactly $5.
The price a rational person is willing to accept for a thing he owns must always be higher than what he values it at.
In a general case, probability of gain is obviously worth less than the same probability of loss, because you need bigger relative return to make up for the loss.