Hacker News Reader

Comment by eknkc | Hacker News Reader

For me the single biggest disadvantage of Go against Node.JS is the lack of a decent dependency management solution. NPM is awesome and Go doesn't even have a "meh" answer to that.

View on HN

I feel and share your pain. I dislike the model of having to vendor in every third party library's source code, so I'm trying to build an alternative tool to Godep[1]. It's still a work in progress but the basic functionality is there :)

[1]: https://github.com/fishworks/dis

What problems have you had managing dependencies with Go? I use Godep to vendor each dependency and rewrite import paths to use the vendored package. I found it to be an easy and effective solution.

NPM is only awesome until you need to do something with it on Windows.

Never had any problem with it when we did a Cordova based application for a customer of ours.

There are quite a few packages in npm that require native compilation of some part of their system during install. These usually fail horribly on windows without spending a lot of time tweaking your system in ways you probably don't want to. This is in sad contrast to how well many of the other libraries just work.

I would have thought it'd be possible to emscripten compile something like tinyC, and make a C compiler you could naturally fit into the node ecosystem to build native libraries.

I see. However that is a common problem in any platform that doesn't follow the UNIX way.

I imagine node.js for IBM i or z/OS to have similar issues.

This is almost certainly true, and if there were as many people trying to use node on those operating systems as there are on windows I expect you would see a similar number of complaints.

What kind of problems are you having with it? I'm using npm on Windows and it's working out great! I'm actually using it as my build/task runner rather than using bloated grunt or gulp. It's easy to configure and read. I run my linter, unit test, jscs, and bundler all configured in package.json.

I also install git bash and conemu to have bash on Windows which makes things much better. I don't use windows console.

My experience is that Npm "kinda works" on Windows. There are mysterious race-conditions and annoying bugs. And I'm not even talking about npm being technically completely incompatible with Windows due to the 256 character path limitation.

I had a global environment variable conflict because something else was named "node.exe"... =/

It's not just npm. A while back I had to set up a Rails dev environment for a client who used Windows. shudder.

Maybe it's just me, but I really like the way Go does package management. Not needing to publish to a central place for packaging is awesome (just have it on any website), but I agree that it needs reorganization (godep is a step in the right direction)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com