Every company/organization/group etc has multiple "dimensions" that they use to determine who is valuable and who is not.
For example, in a technical organization, one dimension might be ability to quickly create production level code. Another dimension might be ability to refactor legacy code.
In a sales organization the dimensions might be different e.g. ability to make existing customers happy vs ability to find new customers.
NOTE: even in the same company, one group may have different dimensions than other groups.
The key is to:
a. figure out which dimensions your company/group/manager are using to define value
b. if there are multiple dimensions, try to find the ones that are easiest/most natural for you but are hardest/least natural for others
c. focus on maximizing b
d. profit
Case in point: I once worked at a high frequency trading firm. I was one of the few people WITHOUT a STEM PhD. However, I was much better, relatively speaking, at over the phone customer interactions/support. Within a month of being there I was made Head of Customer Support purely as a function of being the group member with the best people skills.
Another key point, be wary of creating "Unspoken Covenants" e.g. "If I do X, my manager should do Y".
No they don't.
Go to your manager and say propose a mutually beneficial agreement. e.g.
You: "I would like an increase in salary/title/benefits/vacation days. I know that's a big ask but I know you value sales/code quality/production rate, correct?"
Manager: "Why, yes I do!"
You: "Great. I can improve that thanks to %ABILITY. If I do that can I get my initial ask?"
They should be saying "Hell yes!!" at this point. If not, you may have either misjudged what they value or you are dealing with someone who doesn't believe in mutually beneficial agreements.