I agree with you. Maybe a good idea would be to ask for a credit card, but not to charge it. I think this borders on being illegal though.
I am still pretty happy with 10%, since this was my cut-off for going ahead and building the product.
I am still pretty happy with 10%, since this was my cut-off for going ahead and building the product.
I haven't tried any of this myself since it raises a big issue for me: Doing this makes a promise that you don't intend to keep (at that moment). If trust is what gets users to buy, isn't it counter-productive to violate a user's act of trust?
I'd like to get over this because I can see how experiments like this can be useful and I hope you'll keep us all posted with your success rate. Some things I'm curious to know are:
* How much time passed between your AdWords test and your MVP launch? * Of the emails captured, how many participated in the beta and eventually became paying users?
Best of luck!
Of the emails captured, how many participated in the beta and eventually became paying users?
Which is really asking: Will those users really come back after you've broken that initial promise?
Other success stories say yes. And I speculate that there's a certain window of time that you need to deliver in to make it work.
There'll always be another question though, so I guess it can't hurt to just give it a shot.
Now I got a response that they want to extend a 'special invitation' to use their 'to register on our brand new community site' where I can get involved and maybe new chapters will materialise.
The timing seems pretty convenient. I suspect that the request/suggestion form was really a list building excercise for the community site. It's a Ning. Those things need to cross a substantial chicken-egg hurdle before they are any use to anyone.
I admit, there was no blatant lie. It isn't really exactly the same thing. But it is sending out feelers & building email lists. They could have also put up a big 'join our community' button on the site that led to an 'sorry, under construction' page after you "sign up." Maybe they did. It was a little bit sneaky. I still joined & even started a group. I'm not angry with them. I'll even mention it to others.
Then do the authorize.net CC storage thing where you don't even need to worry about securing private details (pre-auth, don't capture payment till you have a product to sell).