Elon Musk may build Hyperloop test track in Texas | Hacker News Reader

Elon Musk may build Hyperloop test track in Texas

bbc.co.uk

17 points_mulder_7 comments

At this point I've read 2 stories that had little to nothing to contribute past those two tweets that Elon Musk wrote. They don't even link to the actual tweets so that I can read what other discussion might have happened/click the link that he has in his second tweet.

These types of stories are extremely frustrating, they're basically TMZ for tech. I feel like there are very few publications that are willing to publish real stories any more, not just the minimum work that will get clicks. I used to think the BBC was one of them.

Elon should partner with China. They have 10,000 miles of high-speed rail and a maglev $1.2b 19 mile maglev. The distance between Beijing and Shanghai is 800 miles, which would be perfect for the Hyperloop.

Building the first one in China then the second in the US would be faster than building the first one in the US.

Rushing technology development opens up for increased possibility for failures or mistakes. There's no rush to develop the Hyperloop.

It could take 10 years or it could take 20 years. Wouldn't 10 years be better for everyone? China has a "can do" attitude. We seem to have a lot of obstacles in the US. Attitude is definitely one of them. The Manhattan project and the Kennedy moon challenge couldn't be done today. A skunkworks methodology goes a long way:

http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Skunk_Works

The way it seems to best get things done is have an economic benefit that competes with the status quo, and then those who control mass amounts of money will put their money into it to then gain long-term via profits - which unfortunately then makes the cost higher that would otherwise be lower if it was government-people funded first.

Yes that's why I gave you China's motivation. It would connect their two largest cities and China is a big believer in high-speed mass transit.

Good point. China has money to spend in comparison to the U.S. - most of the money the U.S. has spent has been on war, while China's been collecting money from the world. It will be interesting to watch how the landscape shifts in the next few decades.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com