Hacker News Reader

Comment by applecore | Hacker News Reader

Why is Appointment Reminder on a .org top-level domain?

Patrick answers this in his post:

It wasn’t the world’s most inspired naming choice, but the $8.95 I paid for the domain name is probably the best ROI of anything I’ve ever bought. (AR is virtually guaranteed to be a mortal lock on the query [appointment reminder] due to the combination of the exact match domain bonus and the fact that most links to it naturally cite the name of the company. The fact that it is a .org is irrelevant, except in that the .org was $8.95 and the company which owned the .com wanted $30,000 for it.)

SEO. It's a an exact match for the search term he was gunning for, and the .com wasn't available but the .org was. Exact-match domains get hit with the +15 wand of visibility in search results, and the whole .com vs .org distinction isn't as black/white as it used to be.

There was an EMD (Exact Match Domain) update in September 2012 to fix this.

That's a myth. It "reduced" the bonus, but the bonus clearly still exists. But I love that others think that domain name is no longer relevant for SEO. Keep thinking that. :)

It's reduced to the point of not being worth insane prices for EMDs. The majority of his ranking is likely due to his backlink profile and relevant content vs. the domain. I'm sure it doesn't hurt things though.

Yeah, having the name of the company be the same as the top-level keywords makes it so a huge percentage of the backlinks have the anchor text he wants.

Can't speak to "insane prices". But Patrick got AppointmentReminder.org for $8. He classifies it as the best ROI he's ever made.

"cars.com" is still the #1 result for searching "cars". And "business.com" is still on page 1 for searching "business". The death of the EMD has been greatly exaggerated, IMHO.

It's not so much the domain name, but the brand name, which in most cases is the same as the domain.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com