Common LISP is a great language, but it spoils you since it has so few restrictions, its kinda in a class of its own because its just so unrestricted.
Scala is a fine language, but limited, largely serves as gate way drug to other FP languages. Its a very good starting point.
Haskell is odd and the type system is I feel restrictive. Also the community is really addicted to big mathy words. I do love its notation at the same time :\
F# is pretty much universally loved (from what I gather, I haven't used it myself), and now that the .NET run time is unbolted from windows it might start gaining traction.
oCaml I haven't used so I can't comment.
Erlang is VERY popular, especially with the backend FP crowd since it does concurrency very simply. I haven't used it.