Hacker News Reader

I'll update the article to explain a bit more why debugging is described in terms of ptrace: all the other targets work the same way! I studied simulators and corefiles, and they both provide to GDB an interface that is very similar to ptrace. Remote debugging just applies serialization to that interface.

View on HN

Not true in the embedded world. Remote gab will use tag commands, which are fascinating. Basically it's a whole different world. Processors have dedicated hardware support for debugging, far beyond traps and exceptions.

It's amazing that so many embedded processors do this now. Back in the day, you needed to use a special-purpose processor (which had extra pinouts) to do this as part of an in-circuit emulator.

I never had access to the low-level part of embedded systems, although I did my PhD on embedded systems debugging in an embedded system company! what I saw was what was running on the PC and communicating with the JTAG external interface (basically, a `gdbserver` implementation). At that level, that was nothing more than ptrace. Under that, I can't say!

Reply on news.ycombinator.com