Hacker News Reader

Comment by angersock | Hacker News Reader

I'm just curious why the default response is still to reach for an Arduino--much more powerful SoC chips are cheap these days.

View on HN

For us, the reason is that my co-founder and I (both are not hardware guys) were able to build a proof of concept in my garage and Arduino seemed like the best (easiest) choice. Since then, we hired a hardware guy who designed a custom PCB etc. HTTPS would be great but we don't transmit any personal data so it's not a high priority right now.

> HTTPS would be great but we don't transmit any personal data so it's not a high priority right now.

You are sending people's orders around the web. I'd consider that "personal".

None-the-less, use SSL, there is little reason not to use it these days. And as others have pointed out, it's the only good and easy way to guarantee what you send to one of these printers is what it actually received (no carrier tampering of your packets, etc).

Just use SSL.

If SSL isn't supported by the Arduino chipset, then that sounds like more than a "little" reason not to use it. That sounds like it might be an "it would be a whole lot of work" reason not to use it.

(I don't actually know how much work would be involved, but goleksiak says they would really like to use it, so I assume it's not trivial.)

SSL on the Arduino--usually a little 8-bit (!) chip--is a bit resource intensive, in both memory and processing time.

Hey, no worries. Real artists ship. :)

One reason to still use an Arduino is realtime. The arduino's minimalist OS is realtime by default, but the BBB runs non-realtime Debian. They might need RT timings for the printer interface? You can add realtime linux extensions to BBB, but it's not a beginner task -- basically rolling your own Linux installation and writing your app as a kernel module. You can also use the PRU on the BBB to get insane RT performance, but you'll have to code it in assembly. I love the BBB, but Arduino is still an easier package for simple realtime.

Yeah, like any number of Olimex parts. Or a Raspberry Pi Model A.

larger pool of cheap developers, and a hook onto an ongoing popular trend (arduino gizmodery), cheap prototyping.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com