Hacker News Reader

Comment by ultramancool | Hacker News Reader

Seems like it could be a clever way to solve the issue for players, but probably makes developers on those other keyboards quite miserable.

View on HN

a prompt training the game controls could be quite simple... "PRESS THE KEY YOU EXPECT TO BE UP" step 2: "PRESS THE KEY YOU USE FOR FIRE"

I've seen some FPSes get the player's preferred control mappings in a really subtle, cool way: ask the player to perform some actions very early in the game (often as part of a "training" sequence), and configure the controls however necessary to make the user's input correct.

For instance, in Portal 2, to check whether the player wants inverted controls:

http://youtu.be/niE5oiRs7pY?t=45s

That does sound clever but I don't understand your example; in this case, would moving the mouse either way go the intended direction?

It makes more sense for consoles / controllers. Although I am sure /someone/ uses inverted mouse controls. It could be disabled in the PC version also.

Inverted Y (vertical axis, i.e. up/down view) is a very popular setting for simulation games and FPS games on PC. It's popular enough that games with >100k players will get bad press and >20 forum complaints (even when the forum is hard to find!) over it, and many more than this will simply not play/buy the game.

In other genres / types of games, especially where you don't control exclusively one character / vehicle from a fixed first/third person viewpoint, it is drastically less common.

I'm guessing whichever direction your move the mouse, the game looks in the correct direction for you to obey the instructions, and that mapping is then persisted.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com