Hacker News Reader

Comment by jasonkester | Hacker News Reader

A few hundred years late, and a bit on the expensive side compared to its competition:

https://www.google.com/search?q=strap+on+milking+stool&tbm=i...

I built one of these for backpacking trips for a little less than $5 for a wooden disk, a couple plumbing bits and a clip belt. Silly looking when you're walking around with it, but infinitely better than sitting on a wet log next to the campfire.

View on HN

There's some NSFW content in that first page of search results...

Mooooo!

Only if you have safe search turned off.

I didn't turn it off, but that's the default if you block cookies.

The "strap-on milking stool" is not the same thing at all. The chairless chair supports in a range of positions, from standing to sitting.

Also, having to balance on two axes with the milking stool is much harder than with the chairless chair, which only requires you to balance on axis.

It may be more difficult, but it's probably better for you. Before I went full-time standing desk, I sat on an exercise ball all day for years, and my core strength and sense of balance reflect that.

I hear this a lot. Unfortunately the science does not support the idea that sitting on a ball all day will significantly strengthen your core, but it may habitually force you into a better posture (or it may not - be careful). Functionally you'd have the same effect from sitting on a padded stool without a back.

I'm not familiar with the studies you refer to (and you don't explicitly refer to them so I can't check them) but just thought I'd note that core 'strength' could mean either muscular development or neural development of the control of those muscles.

To be clear there isn't a study done on bouncy balls that I know of (there probably is, I didn't look it up), just based on more fundamental science: in terms of physical adaptation there is pretty much no way to increase either neural or muscular development without an increasing intensity of stimulus, which balancing on a ball will not allow you to do. You will probably gain a small amount of both for the first week or two, but then, absent of increasing stress, your body will stop needing to adapt and stabilize.

Come on now, it's very, very similar.

I think with your feet wide you enter a pretty stable tripod stance. And you could easily adjust the length of the chair or give it feet. But since, I presume, neither of us has tried either device, it's all academic, isn't it?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com