Look-and-Say Numbers featuring John Conway [video]
youtube.com
youtube.com
"Somehow it was supposed to guess [the sequence] ... in the end he had to tell me."
Reminds me of those IQ tests were you are supposed to guess the sequence. This sole anecdote is not enough to invalidate the method, but gives me a hint judging someone intelligence by having him complete number sequences (or geometric ones for that matter) may not be that effective.