Ask HN: Feedback on my Idea? | Hacker News Reader

Ask HN: Feedback on my Idea?

2 pointsbluerail7 comments

So, I am planning to build this tool for some days now but not sure whether similar app already exists or not.. Even if there isn't, I doubt if there is audience for this concept..

Concept is : News Topic search:

A simple search box where you'll enter a news topic and it provides a timeline of incidents related to the topic.. It'll basically comes up with the news articles that surfaced and articles that are once trending and conclusion articles and more.. Search terms like "Malaysia flight MH370" "Ebola Breakout"

What do you thing of it? worth pursuing?

View on HN

Google Trends does some of this - http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=microsoft. Letters on the chart are headlines. There's obviously tremendous room for improvement!

GTrends is more of a presenter in terms of providing the trends of a topic.. What I am saying is, say for example, If I search for Satoshi Nakamato it will give me a timeline of worthy news articles that covered that topic right from when it started to the recent one..

The chart is a timeline, the letters are worthy news articles. This is me mousing over "F". You can adjust the dates too = start to finish.

https://www.dropbox.com/s/ipzgu3k45vx9cii/Screenshot%202014-...

how would you differentiate from: http://www.google.com/trends/explore#q=ebola

just more links to the articles?

Is this an aggregator of real-time news, or a curator of old news?

> A simple search box where you'll enter a news topic and it provides a timeline of incidents related to the topic.

Ask yourself whether your app will do this better than Google does. This is not to discourage you, but to ask some hard questions -- to succeed, your app would have to produce something that Google's search engine cannot.

> What do you thing of it?

I thing you need a better, more contextual, spell checker.

First point, Hope so., I have decided to put on some additional features once if this base concept is fine.

Second point, I thing you are right.. My mistake, Irony is doing this right after reading this article https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=8177997

Reply on news.ycombinator.com