Where can I find some precise protocol specifications? The whitepaper is full of handwaving about the critical parts (namely Proof of Resource).
Where can I find some precise protocol specifications? The whitepaper is full of handwaving about the critical parts (namely Proof of Resource).
They (last I checked) are approaching the problem by using quadruple redundancy, no erasure coding. This opens some attack vectors, because an attacker only needs to control 4/4 pieces, something that takes a probability of (attacker control)^4 . Their proof of storage also seems to use nonce's, which require precomputation before uploading the file, and means a limited amount of proofs before you have to fetch the file and compute a bunch of other nonce's.
The biggest problem with MaidSAFE's stuff is that it's all over the place. There's no concise document that explains proof-of-storage. Their approach seems enormously complex, which to me indicates a huge likelihood of undetected vulnerabilities (complexity is bad when you want security).
That paper was written before decentralized storage was really just a new idea. I've since implemented a baseline core algorithm, and we have one application running.
I'm in the process of rewriting the whitepaper. Hopefully will put out a draft in two weeks(I'll be at conferences all this week). From there I want to actually collect network data(after all I'm trained as a researcher and what is good paper without any data?) before putting out a solid draft to be peer reviewed.