If I steal your car and then give you a bicycle, do I get to then say "you can't complain about the theft, you rode here on that bicycle I gave you!"
So how about giving back North-America to the rightful owners?
Since this is by far the largest and longest standing misappropriation of wealth on the continent, I would expect it to be the primary if not sole focus of Libertarians.
And if you DO believe that there is a collective guilt like that, care to elaborate on how it might work? Should just anybody who moves to the US have to pay, even if they did so centuries after the crime? Should just anybody who joins or announces affiliation with an indian tribe receive payment, even if THEY did so centuries after the crime? (If so: I shall have to declare that I am a Hopi Indian. Or a Navajo. Whichever gets me a bigger share.)
Simply if you own land in North America you have bought stolen goods and have no more legitimate claim on it than anyone else.
You can not say "this is mine because I bought it from someone who bought it from someone who stole it from someone"
And people who own no land haven't done anything wrong so no collective guilt at all. Only people own land are guilt. And even they owe nothing more than admitting their claim is bogus (or returning the land to the correct owner). If you can not find the rightful owner of something, that does not mean it is yours to keep. It means it is not yours until you can deal with the correct owner. If you can't find him or his descendents, too bad, you can't claim it any more than anyone else.
>care to elaborate on how it might work
Admit those ideas about private property are simply self serving and that claims to moral unquestionable ownership are bogus. Manage the land accordingly, preferably democratically acknowledging free markets and their limitations.
I'm actually surprised your (weird) claim is so restricted. Why are people who make use of land not also "guilty"? If I work for a company situated on some land, or I drive to work on roads situated on some land, shouldn't that count too?
Then please try not to click on anything you are unsure of while you are visiting, you might unleash the killer robots and the insurance on them is atrocious.
I think this is a problem endemic to the internet.
Voting was created to combat spam, originally, but unfortunately often can effectively become censorship by democracy.