Hacker News Reader

Comment by dwd | Hacker News Reader

Number one rule would be when letting someone register a domain on your behalf that you have access to retrieve the authcode/domain password and preferably can change name servers. I've lost count of how many time I've had to argue with web designers who register a domain for a client and keep it in their own account (a violation of some TLDs T&Cs).

Another situation is the "promotional domain" where you prepay hosting and receive a complimentary domain but not full access to modify it or you have to pay to have it unlocked.

Also be careful with which registrar you check for availability as if you don't buy immediately you may find the domain on their premium list the next day at an inflated price.

View on HN

> Also be careful with which registrar you check for availability as if you don't buy immediately you may find the domain on their premium list the next day at an inflated price.

I have always been scared of that kind of thing, though in the end it never happened to me. So it is a thing then?

Yes, it's called front-running. There have been accusations against some registrars in the tech news.

I just go to register as soon as I'm sure I would like the domain name. That way, worst case it's already registered, best case there's minimal opportunity for front runners.

Even trying it in a browser might alert someone monitoring DNS for interesting NXDOMAIN replies. (Yes, this may be paranoid, but it's hard to keep up with the nefarious tricks that actually go on)

> So it is a thing then?

I've not heard of it happening to anyone in recent years, but Network Solutions were definitely accused of it in 2009, using the 5-day "tasting" period. See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Domain_tasting#Anti-Domain_Tast... for a mention. I would very be surprised to find that it doesn't go on in various places to this day, so for paranoia's sake only search for names you want using known reputable providers.

Way back in is mists of time (~1999/2000, while at University) I had it done to me. We were going to register a name for our student house (and a few other people) and searched for two options both of which were available at the time. A week later when we came back both were registered by the same individual (not directly linked to the company from what we could gather) with a "buy this domain! (for several times the usual cost)" page present. This could have been a coincidence of course, so we looked up a collection of other convincingly real names (from various locations so it wasn't a block of lookups from the same address). A short while later they were all registered the same way, and not on the "5 day" thing either because they all still were a while later. We could have been cruel and search a great many more (had we actually cared about the name(s) we "lost" we might have done) to waste their money but didn't as we had far more important and/or fun things to be getting on with at the time.

I've seen it happen in the past where a client had checked for a domain and when it came to registering it was only available via a premium listing. Only generics, never with country TLDs.

Use a reputable registrar for searching, even better become a reseller and do it via your reseller account.

Unless there are specific rules against it, I could see this becoming worse with all the new TLDs.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com