Hacker News Reader

Comment by Piskvorrr | Hacker News Reader

Perhaps I am missing something - what problem does this solve? Instead of an IPv4 address, you are now entering (optional) prefix, the IPv4 address, and a postfix ".xip.io" Where is the added value over entering the IP address directly?

View on HN

This is very useful for me, because lots of the software I write is SaaS where the customer has their own subdomain - and testing on mobile in a local network is a PITA.

Think of setting acme.example.local and foo.example.local in hosts to 127.0.0.1. In my code I have middleware that sniffs the leftmost part of the hostname and authenticates and routes based on that info.

With this I don't need to mess with hosts, and I don't need to worry about putting in a hack for mobile (on which you cannot change any hosts).

You can set up your web server to serve different applications on different domains if you're working on multiple projects at the same time and don't want to put them on different ports or use subdirectories.

Another use case I can see is for testing subdomain-based web apps where you give each customer a subdomain (really just a wildcard dns record), e.g. acme.myapp.com

Yeah, that makes sense, thanks.

Why not just customizing /etc/hosts then... You guys are relying too much on 3rd party tools without knowing what they do with your data and what they're becoming in the future.

Testing web page with custom subdomain in a mobile devices, passing a test URL to co-workers, etc. I did this a lot, even though I have my own DNS server setup for this purpose in my own LAN, I could see myself using this if I don't already have the DNS set up.

How do you customize /etc/hosts on an iPad?

In most cases, customizing /etc/hosts would require every person working on a project to customize their /etc/hosts the same way. It becomes a burden when somebody wants to add or change an entry. They would need to email everybody who works on the project to tell them all to make the same change.

It's a DNS server. The only data they can get from you is what you're calling the subdomains on your apps.

Yes, you could achieve the same functionality by editing /etc/hosts, but that's a pain in the arse if you're rapidly switching between a set of different sites, or if you want to access a coworker's machine in the same way.

You guys are complaining too much about useful hacker-friendly tools from well-known companies.

Editing /etc/hosts also requires root access, which becomes an issue if you're running tests on a shared server that's locked down, rather than just on your PC.

If you're developing an app that relies on wildcard subdomain matching - all the organization-oriented apps that give you a your-team-name.example.com URI, for instance - fiddling with /etc/hosts is going to become a chore.

Using this service doesn't touch our "data" in any way whatsoever. It's a DNS service; it's not like I need to give them access to my Postgres database and Google Analytics password.

The server is open source[1] so you could always run your own if you're paranoid.

[1] https://github.com/sstephenson/xipd

This is run by 37signals, so should be pretty legit.

For local testing you can simply use the whole 127.0.0.0/8 subnet. If your webserver's listening socket is bound to the any-local address (0.0.0.0) then you can setup 127.0.0.1, .2, ... , 127.255.255.254 as vhosts.

No need for DNS or different ports.

You can test your app on mobile devices in the same network without having to mess with the hosts file.

my use case: some of services won't allow me to interact with them (i.e. oauth) unless I register a domain. 127.0.0.1 and "localhost" do not work, 127.0.0.1.xip.io inexplicably does.

you can use pow(or prax under linux) or just edit the /etc/hosts to point example.dev to your localhost

Same question, I don't see the point of such a tool excepted propagating this stupid .io TLDs madness.

What do you have against the TLD?

I have something against stupid trends. io is a gcc TLD, shouldn't be polluted just because everybody thinks it's the cool 2014 way to build something hype.

Anyway, out of subject.

Even the registry themselves[0] promote it outside of just a normal country gcctld

[0]http://nic.io

At 72GBP/year, they can.

29€ on Gandi.

Remember that .com was only ment for commercial ventures, .org for non-government organizations and .net for network providers? [1]

I guess the 'TLD's shouldn't be polluted' ship has sailed quite some time ago.

[1] http://tools.ietf.org/html/rfc1591

Yes, the 4000 British and American military officers stationed in the Indian Ocean Territory need to have access to this TLD.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com