Hacker News Reader

Comment by ska | Hacker News Reader

It's hardly a new approach - people have tried this sort of thing for decades. I don't know of any significant adoption analysis, but it pops up as an idea fairly regularly.

edit: There is some confusion; this was a response to parents "More importantly, this opens it up a new approach that can be used in lots of places.", not to the article. It doesn't really open anything up.

I think it was a fine school project, fwiw.

View on HN

You and I know that, but presumably the kid didn't.[1]

I understood this as a story about hacker spirit in a kid, and it made me smile.

[1]: If he did already know, and presented this idea as his own? He may not be a great hacker, but he has a promising future as a manager.

"he has a promising future as a manager."

Or, if this actually leads to adoption, a salesman.

I really hope you and 6cxs2hd6 are being tongue in cheek. First, this kid clearly has a good head on his shoulders, and is even able to do some pretty cool technical stuff that most of the population cannot. Second, judging someone based on a single action you've seen from them is... less than scientific. By that logic you should be a "short comment writer" :).

Note that the conversational tangent my comment was in response to was "if it wasn't actually his idea". In that case, the thing it best shows is that he did a good job presenting it. Which is itself a valuable skill, is my point. Obviously there's a question of how well the little we know about him generalizes, regardless of what skills we're considering.

I guess I should also note, I hadn't meant "salesman" to be derogatory...

Re "manager", yes I was being mostly tongue in cheek; I recently re-read The Gervais Principle and was thinking of Sociopaths. :)

http://www.ribbonfarm.com/the-gervais-principle/

I'm sure it's not a totally original idea, but if this gets enough publicity it might push for actual innovation.

As a somewhat related anecdote I was repeatedly told by my professors that in Physics everything is named after the last person to discover it, not the first.

And in mathematics, because you can't name everything after Euler.

(ref. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_things_named_after_Leon...)

Yeah, but he was just that good.

I can't find the quote now, but I'm sure that I've read of someone saying (when told that a result had been found earlier but forgotten), "Yes, but when I discovered it, it stayed discovered!"

It may not be a new approach. But I liked how the kid experimented and tried to think of other ways to solve an issue.

It's the spirit behind that counts. It can lead to other interesting hacking endeavors down the road in that young man's life.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com