Comment by nl | Hacker News Reader

Comment by nl | Hacker News Reader

Parent Full thread

I'm concerned that giving comment-approval power to people with x amount of karma will reinforce many of the existing problematic aspects of HN instead of opening it up to better discussion

Given that endorsement is a mechanism which can only reduce the quantity of discussion on HN, it is difficult to imagine that it is designed to open up a discussion to more viewpoints.

I think your choice of "female work experience in technology fields" is interesting because it is one of the few legitimate topics where there isn't widespread agreement on basic foundations around the topic.

Others topics that fall into that category include "The Economics of Bitcoin", "Is Google Evil", "Startup X was bought by large company Y".

There's also a wide range of political & economic topics which are always controversial, but sometimes I question their legitimacy as a topic for HN.

I wonder if these controversial topics should have special handling so far as endorsement (and maybe even voting) on comments goes?

Given that endorsement is a mechanism which can only reduce the quantity of discussion on HN

That seems a mistaken assumption. The presence of existing comments often causes me to refrain from posting comments. Often I've been about to reply to something, then notice someone else has already said substantially the same thing, and as a result don't.

And this is not a contrived example. As I said when I first launched pending comments, if someone says something important in a nasty way, it may well turn out to be safe not to endorse it, because someone else will probably show up and make the same point without nastiness.

Plus if HN gets more civil, it may encourage people to comment who might not have before. I know from my own experience that incivility has decreased the number of comments I make. I often find myself about to say something, then decide I have work to do and don't have time to spend the afternoon fighting, and so don't say it.

Only experience can tell us whether one or both of these factors will increase the number of comments, but we can't assume that pending comments can only reduce discussion.

Often I've been about to reply to something, then notice someone else has already said substantially the same thing, and as a result don't.

Hm. Interesting...

I guess unique insights aren't, generally.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com