Hacker News Reader

Comment by Jake232 | Hacker News Reader

Thanks! I mentioned BeautifulSoup existed very briefly in the lxml section in prerequisites. I just added a short section on CSS Selectors, you can actually use lxml with them. I'll add a little more info with BeautifulSoup and PyQuery mentioned though.

View on HN

People who write (python) crawlers use BeautifulSoup because it was created with invalid input in mind. If you're crawling the wild wild internet, chances are you'll find a wide range of invalid markup and lxml barfs on those (it's got recover=True, but that's not supported for all things lxml does).

I've wrote a lot of python crawlers, and have never really experienced an issue with lxml. It doesn't really ever seem to choke, and I'm sure I must have come across some pretty funky markup in my time. lxml has always handled things fine for me. Maybe I've just gotten lucky I guess?

That's not actually lxml's fault, it depends on the libxml2 installed in your environment. Just like Jake232, I haven't found a site that lxml can't handle lately, using libxml 2.9.1. You can find your libxml2 version in Python with:

  >>> from lxml import etree
  >>> etree.LIBXML_VERSION

If you find a page in the wild that it can't handle, I'd love to know the URL.

Even BeautifulSoup makes use of lxml now (as of version 4)

Reply on news.ycombinator.com