Hacker News Reader

Hmmm, he's been to Ghana. Clearly he's an expert on the situation in Africa, because that country is so typical.

How is it not? Certainly, one can't overgeneralize about such a huge continent. But it's neither South Africa, nor is it Somalia.

Ghana and (southern) Nigeria, where this guy has been, are among the most urbanized parts of the continent.

There are a lot of dense conurbations and they are fairly close to one another. That's obviously relevant for cell service.

Many parts of e.g. east and central Africa have lower-density settlement patterns that may be tougher to cover.

Much closer to the former than the latter, according to the Failed States Index Rankings:

http://ffp.statesindex.org/rankings

On that list, Somalia is ranked 1, while Ghana and South Africa are 110 and 113 respectively. (For comparison, Finland is the champ at 178.) Certainly there are other ways to compare nations, and Ghana is not a perfect society. However, Ghana is exceptional among African nations, and it is a measure of the cluelessness of TFA that this fact isn't mentioned.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com