EDIT: I should also note that I'm one of those who switched over to DuckDuckGo for privacy reasons, so I don't see these results as often now.
I want content that is curated by people who actually understand the subject. I would pay for a search engine designed by someone who understands my industry. The Google algorithm only manages to grab at the low hanging fruit. I am a professional working on real stuff, I want something better than coffee shop suggestions.
To give some idea I've asked for a list of URLs to documents covering best current practice for suicide prevention in Gloucestershire and Herefordshire; to include national level NHS and NICE guidance, DoH guidance, anything from Gloucestershire and Herefordshire, and anything recognised as excellent from anywhere else in the country. If possible I also want a list of protocols used in schools, care homes, etc.
It's probably something you could risk on MTurk. Perhaps Bountify.com could expand to this kind of simple websearching.
Obvious drawbacks include delay between starting the search and getting the results, and cost, and having to trust some random person to not miss stuff.
I don't know if there's anything similar to "clippings services" either where you'd provide them with list of types of stories you'd want, and they'd read all the newspapers and clip any relevant stories and post them to you.
"I would pay for a search engine designed by someone who understands my industry"
What industry is that? And how would Google guess or know your industry unless you tell them?
An option to disable the personalization of search and going back to seeing the top 10 results for a search term that everyone sees would go against the core strategy that Google and others pursue these days.
The idea is to gain information about you and give you personalized advertisement and services. This has been criticized with the term Filter Bubble [1]. Consider your phrasing "I just want search results", similarly the terms "have you googled it" or "let me google that for you".
Quaint.