Hacker News Reader

>> or that releasing coins for privileged customers would help MtGox...

I don't agree with that. If this person got his coins back, people would have gained a little faith that MtGox might actually get back on its feet. So at least that'd be positive PR for them. The fact that this guy did not get his coins back suggests to me that the situation, whatever it is, must be very serious and lowers my faith that MtGox will recover.

View on HN

As pointed out by another reply, if this user had gotten his withdrawal processed, it would show that you more or less have to fly to Japan in person to get your money. If that precedent were set I believe that would negatively impact MtGox's PR in a pretty substantial way.

I'm not disagreeing with what you're saying. It would show that they at least 'have funds' to pay out, rather than what looks like them not having anything (or enough) to cover the coins. I just think that the realization that you need to fly to Japan would also cause a lot of negative PR for them.

Oh, definitely there'd be some people saying "Hey! That's not fair! We can't all fly to Japan", but I suspect the overall effect would be a net-positive. At least, after the the people yelling "unfair!" calm down. Might take a week or 2.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com