Just curious, why do you not allow the interviewee to use jQuery? Do you expect the candidate to know JavaScript's DOM-level APIs without having to look them up?
The DOM API isn't very large/complicated, and it shouldn't be hard to MOSTLY memorize it. It isn't a "gotcha" question though, a good interviewer is not gonna ding the heck out of you if your forget bits of it (most web devs do spend most of their time with jQuery, YUI, etc after all) - it's about whether you understand what's going on behind the scenes.
After all, I often have to look up a rarely used method. Seems unfair to judge harshly if they do so.