Hacker News Reader

Comment by dasil003 | Hacker News Reader

If they want to hire 18-year-old hackers than it's probably okay, but I'm 30, love a fun work environment, and I'm pretty turned off by being so flip about CS. How can you praise a candidate for loving Haskell but be so arrogant to think CS has no value.

View on HN

I imagine that it has no value to them. They're not out to create any new algorithms/systems/compilers/languages, simply to make proper use of the ones in existing libraries. To put it in the way they'd likely say it: "Ninja don't forge katana."

I don't understand, they don't care about cs principals, rather they want a 'ninja' who is able to write obscure code in languages people rarely use and is hard to understand.

WHY would anyone want this?

I realize that there are a lot of crappy degree programs out there, but this just plain wrong-headed. CS theory is applicable to anyone writing any kind of software more complex than simple one-off scripts. In fact I would argue that most of a proper CS program is more applicable to more practical problems than 90% of what you do in real world jobs. That's not to say you need CS to be a good programmer or anything silly like that, but the scope of things you learn in a CS degree is pretty much impossible to attain in the workplace without working on an amazing array of different projects.

It's not that CS has no value. It's that formal education in CS may not be what it's cracked up to be.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com