Hacker News Reader

I wonder how it would work out if teams actually structured their offenses around gaining only 2.5 yards per down; not averaging 2.5, but actually gaining 2.5?

Of course, they'd have to go deeper now and again just to keep the offense on its toes, but apart from that 2.5 is the goal. Everything else is a bonus.

If successful, they would also control the clock and keep the other team's defense on the field.

View on HN

You'd have football as it was played 50 years ago?

Heh. Bring out the leather helmets.

But, that may be the reason it could work.

I would think that would imply a heavy running game, which would break down your backs very quickly. (A whole lot of Option)

That being said, if you recruited for that it would be an interesting strategy.

Yeah, well, and quick outs, slants, short passes underneath, etc.

Actually, now that I think of it, maybe the playbook wouldn't have to change too dramatically. You may run the ball a bit more, but you'd still run pass plays that spread the field out. If the defense just gives you the deep play, you take it. But, you're content to go with the first play that nets you 2.5, so you make that the goal and always have a couple of short options. The QB then prioritizes those in his progression.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com