So if they aren't apparently trying to maximize their personal profits as measured in dollars, then they are failures. That's quite a harsh generalization.
The ones who end up at typical startup management jobs are the bottom of the class, though. They weren't good enough for stat-arb hedge funds or billion-dollar deals, so they got stuck managing nerds.
If someone 10 years out of an MBA program with some success to his name said that he wanted to run a tech startup, I'd be inclined to support him. On the other hand, if he was a fresh Stanford grad and couldn't do better than a VP-level position at a Series A or B startup, I'd be inclined to think he was a third-stringer.