Hacker News Reader

This was software aimed at people seriously studying the bible with a reminder that would come up when they're reflecting on their religion. And you think that's irrelevant?

They've already pirated the software so it's not morality, it's guilt.

View on HN

Is it even meaningful to talk of guilt without morality?

While both are social responses derived from some societal "standard" and ones interaction with it; the former, I typically think of, as being more of an involuntary reaction, whereas the later is thought of as motivating conscious behavior. The often hypocritical actions of people who will do something until they get caught, is the big example. Clearly it is not against someones personal morals, but it does generate a response due to a negative interaction with another member of society, which in many cases might be motivated by guilt.

Terrible wording aside, I think the two have both intersecting and unique qualities, guilt and morality, that depending on the person will be called into play at various points in the decision making process.

Disclaimer: IANAbehaviorist, I was just raised by one, and nearly married to one.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com