Hacker News Reader

So no one has the right to, for example, clean water?

Or is that just egalitarian bullshit that is going to make everyone the same in every aspect too?

Governments exist to give everyone a basic set required services. I think even the biggest free market/ small government advocate would agree that access to clean drinking water is one of those services.

If you dismiss some things the government provides as being unnatural, you are drawing a very crooked line of "naturality" if you somehow manage to include clean drinking water.

But access to college and health care isn't??

Well, that depends on the government. All the way from the very basic necessities to keep citizens alive to a guaranteed minimum income and full health, education and other services.

I don't think that there is any right level for all countries.

Access to health care gets conflated with some universal or Obamacare-type system, though.

Case in point: my grandparents are on medicare. They pay basically nothing for it. One of them just had bypass surgery and the other a knee replacement. Cost to them: $0.

We pretty much have universal access healthcare in the US before the Obamacare stuff if you go through the system.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com