I'd like to see any citation for #1.
For #2 you need to prove that if there exists s in S and s has property X then every element t in S also has property X.
For #2 you need to prove that if there exists s in S and s has property X then every element t in S also has property X.
And let's not forget that, for a novel product, the baseline for safety is not using the product, not using something that is known to be extremely toxic.
+ I know that nicotine has LD50, so does water and even oxygen is dangerous at high pressure.