Google used 'Android is open' as a dishonest slogan to convince developers that it wasn't just a power play.
That is why they are being criticized. It's not about who is more open. It's that Google misled everyone about their intentions.
That is why they are being criticized. It's not about who is more open. It's that Google misled everyone about their intentions.
Unfortunately, this highlights some weaknesses in the GPLv2, which is supposed to guarantee freedom.