Hacker News Reader

Comment by unono | Hacker News Reader

No, this ain't non-profit, it's big profit stuff.

Khan academy is definitely not it. They teach traditional curriculum which is isn't useful to business.

The app is definitely isn't the easy part - it is basically the whole part. The current education system is a failure for 2 reasons

- unanalyzed teaching

- unmotivated students

Apps solve both problems, every user interaction recorded and analyzed, gamification.

You can turn it around even and starting hiring those students yourself and create your own megacorp with the best employees and make megabucks.

View on HN

1) The absolute last thing this world needs is more for-profit education, particularly for-profit education that has somebody else foot the bill. Do yourself a favor and try to sell this idea as non-profit; I was giving you the benefit of the doubt by assuming it was.

2) An app that teaches people things but doesn't have anything to teach them is worthless. Of course the software is the easy part...

If you really think a for-profit Khan Academy that teaches... nontraditional... curriculum, but doesn't actually have any content since you seem to be completely ignoring that problem... is what the world really needs, then pitch it to YC as a for-profit startup. I ain't stopping you...

I think we'll keep disagreeing about this.

I think your argument comes from the traditional 'liberal arts' education angle.

I'm coming more from vocational type place. More of a rentacoder/odesk done more comprehensively.

Anyway, adios

I'm not worried about liberal arts education. I couldn't care less about that.

I'm just wondering how you think making an app would be the difficult part of teaching thermodynamics or fluid mechanics to people.

Khan got famous for explaining concepts really well. There were plenty of online stuff covering it already. He just did a superior product.

Same with the app. It needs to be excellent, something Steve Jobs would be proud of, and it will make dent in the universe.

This is big, heady, stuff, and we'll kill the ed business with it. I like nothing better than to see government jobs disappear.

Why would it need to be an app at all? It has zero benefits over being a website and requires students to buy an expensive piece of hardware to access it.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com