He's not saying that this is a good thing he's using this as an example of how broken the medical system is. Did you read to the end? Or did you just get annoyed after the first few paragraphs and write this screed?
He's not saying that this is a good thing he's using this as an example of how broken the medical system is. Did you read to the end? Or did you just get annoyed after the first few paragraphs and write this screed?
But he completely fails to take into account the fact that healthcare is about as far from an efficient market as you can get:
1. Patients often need healthcare right now or they will die which does not give them the time, opportunity or mindset to weigh alternatives and make an informed choice.
2. Patients are often unconscious when healthcare decisions must be made.
3. Patients are constrained in their choices by time and place. When you need healthcare, you often need it immediately and are unable to travel, which means you can only choose from the venues nearby.
4. Quality of product is nigh impossible for a patient to ascertain. You might be able to find the outcome history for a few care providers you're considering, but that presumes you can reliably tell which doctor will actually be the one to give you care. If you take a turn for the worse when they're off duty, now it's out of your hands.
5. Patients can't pick and choose pieces of care. Assuming somehow you do have the data to make decisions about which nurses, facilities, equipment, doctors, and anesthesiologists you want, you can't pick and choose them and assemble your own A-Team.
No one argues that the medical system isn't broken, but arguing that we should replace it with individual customer chosen free markets is making the claim that somehow a bunch of stressed out amateurs with little time or medical knowledge who are currently suffering a medical malady will somehow be able to bargain more effectively than what we see now.
But, this is not how the free market works. When I bought my entertainment centre it cost around $3000 after haggling ... the MRSP for all the pieces was around $3500.
This example was the MRSP was $23000 AFTER the insurance covered a bunch of it. The negotiated cost was $3000.
In a free market system the MRSP would come down and none of these points would really matter (the constrained people would pay $3500 instead of the haggled price of $3000)