1. People don't know about it.
2. Are the outcomes comparable?
3. Legal protection - you will have hard time suing Indian specialist in India and there won't be much damages to extract anyway.
4. Age? A good chunk of people that need that types of surgeries are well covered by Medicare.
5. You also need plane tickets, recovery time and at least one companion - so you may look at a lot higher total cost.
6. Plain old fear/ racism.
And the moment it becomes common there will be the full media smear campaign, scaremongering etc
However, ironically enough, the USA has a booming medical tourism industry also. At about 60-80k, it is only half as small as India (150,000), though nowhere near Thailand (1.42 million).
"Need a heart bypass? We'll give you $10k and waive the co-pay if you do it in India"