It may be too big of a transition, but I really like crunchbang. I would just spin up a VM for each ubuntu, mint, crunchbang, and centos, and see what floats your boat.
For vps/server I prefer centos/debian.
edit: also wanted to add that crunchbang has run much faster for me than lubuntu which I previously was using. Generally ~200-250mb ram, boots extremely quick as well. It will run great on an old junk pc, or a new workstation.