I tried Feedly but I didn't like how slick & clever it is. It seems to decide (based on popularity) which new posts to show me, when all I really want is a categorized listing of everything that's new. I like a good old-fashioned list where some things are 'unread' and some things are 'read', but in Feedly this seems to be fuzzy concept.

After trying a few other services and apps, I switched to NetNewsWire, which is a client-side Mac app that does what I want. Pretty happy so far.