Hacker News Reader

Comment by _k | Hacker News Reader

Putin didn't really say they support the US's surveillance state, he said surveillance is necessary but you need a warrant.

View on HN

Yeah, careful with that guy. A lot of people who didn't get on with him seem to die in strange ways. But don't talk about it - especially not Pussy Riot style as dissent isn't ok.

You know, I find it puzzling that, even though USA has proven itself to be literally on the same level as the "communist" countries(read: China, Russia), people still apply selective blindness.

People die in strange ways in the states too. Michael Hastings much?

> though USA has proven itself to be literally on the same level as the "communist" countries

And people wonder why I complain about seeing political discussions on this site. How can you have a serious discussion with bizarre comments like the above? And just so it's clear: one can simultaneously hold in one's mind the view that there are some serious imperfections and injustices in the US, and that there are a lot of worse places - and some that are probably better.

If by serious imperfections and injustices you mean the violation of fundamental human rights, including freedom of speech, that America flaunts right and left.

"What makes America the greatest country in the world? re: Freedom and freedom, and let's keep it that way."

And you've got your blinkers on if you think that's really the worst it can get, or if you think Putin "really isn't that bad".

That's not at all what I said. The difference is that Putin doesn't spread propaganda through every news channel about how Russia is a truly democratic country and everyone has their freedoms according to the law. Everyone KNOWS he is a tyran, and he doesn't do much to change that.

Now let us observe the american media - 1)America birthplace of freedom? check. 2)America greatest country in the world? check. Despite not leading the world in a single category(besides defense spending). 3)Ideologically and officially different but pragmatically similar political parties? check. America - the birthplace of hypocrisy and the God complex.

So this is you being one of those Americans who thinks America is the center of everyone's world. Putin, doesn't broadcast on American networks, in America, because they're American.

What do you think happens in Russia?

I'm eastern european, meaning I do have some inside knowledge on how Russia operates, especially since it's still trying to regain political power in the post-soviet countries 23 years after its fall. Everybody knows Russia wants its old empire back.

I do believe my perception of the american media is accurate as well. You're free to dispute that.

Here in Russia we have our own PRISM since 90-s.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SORM

SORM is used for selective surveillance (by adjudication) and not even close for total monitoring programs like PRISM.

Can you elaborate on this or offer a link?

I agree that PRISM is worse since they spy on almost all the world Internet traffic and phone calls, but I wouldn't trust Russian Government to only spy with a warrant.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com