Hacker News Reader

Comment by duey | Hacker News Reader

Could also just name your hosts appropriately and use something like puppet to create and update DNS records for your hosts automatically.

View on HN

Yeah, as a neckbearded network and systems engineer I really don't understand this thing at all - it should be a non-issue. Specifically, because the OP states the machines are mostly dedicated machines, there should be absolutely no reason why they don't have dedicated hostnames in DNS, either locally or globally.

At organizations where I have held the above titled roles, DNS was one of first things to be put into service if it had not already been used. Connecting to the IP address of a dedicated machine by a nice name is pretty much what the DNS was invented for. DNS is very much not static and if you are changing a host's IP very often, you can set it up such that the DNS responds appropriately with the proper up to date IP address.

OP's script is nice but... it's solving an already solved problem, IMO.

Confused me as well, since this is pretty much what DNS is for - I spent some time trying to figure out the problem being solved...

The problem is he doesn't know how to use DNS. :-)

Another great way is to just modify ~/.ssh/config To something like this:

host alias hostName thehostname user your_username

I like the work in the article, but many times when I think I need to whip up a sweet script to fix some problem in the terminal I find the old neckbeards already wrote it, polished it, and left it on the shelf for me to use.

/etc/hosts ?

Reply on news.ycombinator.com