I'm reluctantly probably to go with Feedly for now, even though the "slickness" of the experience really gets in the way, the preferences are limited, and the page-by-page flipping on Android is maddening. I skim in streams, not blocks.

Newsblur was my second choice, but I found it too busy and cumbersome. That arrow that follows your mouse vertically that you can lock/unlock was the last straw.