Engineering doesn't work that way. Your proposed solution doesn't become more sound simply because you feel aggrieved at the way people react to it.
Also: it's deeply dishonest to suggest that the only reaction you've received to this design is "snark". As I pointed out above, with a link and everything, and as you yourself acknowledged in your original post, you've been given a litany of reasons why your proposed design is flawed. You just don't seem to like hearing them.