Show HN: Nuuton UI demo. Give me your feedback.
nuuton.com
nuuton.com
Not sure why you would have the search button not a button. With forms like this I would either have the button or nothing and expect users to hit the enter key.
The colours a fine in my opinion (although I am not a designer) but the amount of negative space around elements is too much.
The placeholder text in the input box is a bit weird. I would remove the reference to nuuton.
B: Are "Hacker News", "/r/programming" etc search results? Trending topics that will be replaced when a search is made? It is hard to tell since it is not functioning.
C: The search placeholder is also confusing. " ..: Nuuton :... /category !description" Again, does "..: :.." have any significance or is this like having "google" as the placeholder in their search field? Is "/category" intended to tell the user they can narrow a search to a certain sub-reddit?
D: Are you trying to brand your product through the search field placeholder? Put your brand/ logo somewhere in the green area instead. You loose all branding when a query is entered into the search field.[2]
Hope I'm not coming across as mean, I think the items I listed above will be some stumbling blocks to new users interacting with your site.
Also, honestly, it looks rather amateur -- which is okay, it being a work in progress.
I have no idea what any of the things below the form field are so I can't comment on that.
As for positives... I like the ASCII picture of Isaac Newton in the source.
This needs a lot of work, but everything starts somewhere.
- too much whitespace around the search input. I can only see three results
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
- results text is too large
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
The launch version will have up to 50 results.
- the input placeholder is confusing. is that the accepted syntax? why is "nuuton" in it?
No good reason. The / and ! are tools that you will be able to use to search.
- it lacks context. what was matched? is this up-to-date content? what is the domain/URL? where do I click?
Did not put that in here on purpose, due to this being an UI exercise. I do agree its confusing.
- large pink footer. why? shrink it and leave it for legalese
My daughter's input. (:
- the ..: :.. thing brings me memories of Geocities
Those are placeholders.
So you're saying it's possible to move around the page?
> And no, Nuuton is not dead. Its more alive than ever.
What is Nuuton? (strike that, answered above)