PreZentit, Our Startup (Online PreZentations). Asking for feedback. | Hacker News Reader

PreZentit, Our Startup (Online PreZentations). Asking for feedback.

prezentit.com

29 pointsgerman45 comments

We have been working on this for the last four months. It's an online presentations editor that allows a team to edit the same presentation simultaneously.

Feedback is really appreciated. (We will apply to YC this week).

Open articleView on HN

Nice work! Regarding your application to YC, I'd guess that if this were a past project, and now you were doing something that wasn't this, YC would accept you in a heartbeat. You guys could even be one of the "leave the 'what will you make?' field blank" groups, and get accepted.

But, YC already funded a very similar company. I wonder if they would have reservations about funding a competitor. Perhaps not, given that Zenter has been acquired, but I don't know.

I was going to say that another issue is going head-to-head against Google. But I now don't think that's so much of a problem. Yahoo and Microsoft are going to need their own versions of Powerpoint, and I think they'd totally snap this up.

We have been working on this for the last four months. It's an online presentations editor that allows a team to edit the same presentation simultaneously.

Feedback is really appreciated. (We will apply to YC this week).

Your timing could be better.

Very nice work. I tried the editor and was impressed.

+ I love the way the font size changed as I mouseover'd.

+ ALL of the text in the front page graphics looks like its messed up. I guess it was some effect that was supposed to look nice, but it just looks blurry/jagged to me.

+ It wasn't immediate obvious how to "try it".

+ I do not like the fullscreen popup "Try it" link. I would much prefer a new window or just the same window.

+ I created a little presentation and then clicked "Publish" which gave a weird blank window (because I'm not registered I assume). Then I looked elsewhere before finding "Show". Maybe I'm slow, but that was confusing and I almost gave up before seeing what my presentation looked like.

+ I want an account with a sub-domain "rep", so I can login at http://rep.prezentit.com/

We were afraid of Google slides... but now not so much.

Looks pretty slick.

I really, really dislike clicking on the try-it link and getting a fullscreen-ish popup. Someone, somewhere that knows something about design must have a list that includes "Don't change my window size, unless you're a musician."

The "Try It" link should be huge, in the middle of the page, and not below the fold.

That's a good one, I'll start working on it right now!

Maybe I should make also a Sign Up button next to it.

(Try It) (Sign Up)

I think of placing those buttons below the tag line.

Thanks.

I just added a Try it button, thanks for the suggestion =)

wow. a pleasure to use and look at. And there is already more than enough features to be useful.

Only one thing: it would be better to me if the site would fit in one or two windows. Now I have:

 1- the web site
 2- the working presentation
 3- the running presentation

That's a lot of windows for one website.

You're right.

We did it because:

- The working presentation was easier to work in a new window (bigger workspace).

- The running presentation needs a new window to be in full screen.

We are thinking in previewing the presentation in the editor, so you will have just 2 opened windows.

Also, if you just want to run the presentation you can do it directly from the website.

What do you think about that solution?

a preview in the editor looks like a must indeed, for that and other reasons.

More comments: If I'm editing a presentation, switch windows, and go to the presentation list, if I choose one and click edit, the working presentation is automatically saved (gasp) and the editor does not come into focus either (although that might be KDE's focus stealing prevention at work).

Preview in the editor... done.

1> no obvious demo button to see the tool in action

2> why I gotta register

3> can I upload powerpoints?

That's a review of your web site, not your web application, but that's kind of the point - I didn't get to your application, because your web site is in the way.

Demo, on the home page, using your own tool to pitch me your own tool.

Thanks for that,

1> Well, you can try it, pressing the Try it link ( you're right it should be a button).

2> You need o be registered to access your presentations, editing, and managing them. (We should also explain it too).

3> No, you can't upload powerpoints yet.

Have you tried the presentation editor?

Does it have OpenDocument support?

I tend to use desktop apps for this kind of thing, but for on-the-go editing while travelling, or remote presenting, this would be really useful. All my existing presentations are in OpenDocument tho.

On your feedback page is this sentence:

"Your opinion is very important for us since it help us to build a better preZentit for everyone. "

Proper grammar would be <i>since it helps us to. . .</i>

Just some feedback.

Can you put up a few sample presentations that I can just go and view right away? (I guess there will be some under Explore soon). The editor looks very professional and cool but I want to see the end result too.

Here is a sample PreZentation.

http://prezentit.com/german/6

Hope you like it :P

Is there a way to go full-screen? I hit F11 but there is still a small bar at the top of the screen.

I have to agree. I think many users will expect an on-screen fullscreen button as in youtube or er.. 'google presentations'.

IE7? No, that bar is for "security". Firefox/Opera/etc: real fullscreen.

Firefox 3

That's weird. Are you opening the presentation in a tab? I'm trying it in Ubuntu and Windows XP and it works as it should (no bar).

I like it, good work, but there should be a 'close window' button on the final slide.

good catch!!

Thanks.

Clicking on the thumbnail should start the show.

Pretty slick. Can anyone that used the real Zenter make a comparison?

This one is missing quite a bit of the graphic stuff that Zenter had (but seems to have lost for Google Presentations). Rotations of text and images and browsing of Flickr and Google Images for images with drag and drop. Font handling in Zenter was also awesome to behold. It tried to replicate some of the really hard stuff in PowerPoint, that this one doesn't (yet).

Looks very slick, though. Definitely a contender, particularly if Google Presentations doesn't bring in all of that functionality that we were seeing in Zenter before it got sucked up by Google. The design is nice and clean, too, which is a plus.

We are working on the graphic stuff right now, we have awesome ideas for it, I think we should have it done in a couple of weeks.

I think that one of the things that makes us different is the ability to edit presentations between a group of people in real time.

We worked a lot on the design too, we believe that a good tool must have a nice design and be easy to use.

"I think that one of the things that makes us different is the ability to edit presentations between a group of people in real time."

I'm pretty sure Zenter was already demoing this feature, as well. You've picked a hard target to top. ;-)

Given your username, that's just weird, but I loaded it from Germany, and I got a web page in Spanish. Google correctly loads as google.de, so something must be wrong on your side.

I'm not from Germany, my name is German (it's a Spanish name). We will have the site translated to German in a couple of days.

change Cintributors to Contributors

http://prezentit.com/help/contribute

;-)

changed (thanks)

I see pre zen tit on the front page image.

Very neat. Some of the demo slides ( I think the 9th one) disappeared faster than others.

This is fantastic but can you try and get it working properly in Opera and Safari? :D

Great execution. Bad concept. Been there done that. good luck.

About the concept, can you please tell me what is wrong with it so we can think about changing.

Thanks.

Again i want to stress that you did great work. However as to the concept, your what people call a "me too" company. Alot of other companies doing the same thing at the same time. Yes you are a little bit different ,but not enough that most people will pick over .....google or whoever. If you can figure a way to interact with other service and provide features that they not have that might work.

Did you work on this alone or with a team?

Thanks, we work are a team of 2 co-founders: juanpablo and me.

I like it, its good. You could work on the name though. :)

I don't think the name is all that bad. All the good ones are taken, so you've got to go outside the realm of good spelling to get something even close to appropriate.

very nice

Reply on news.ycombinator.com