Hacker News Reader

Comment by bluetooth | Hacker News Reader

Welp, it looks like it's time to move to Amazon EC2. It's cheaper and hasn't (to my knowledge) been hacked yet.

Not sure why HN is full of so many fair-weather friends these days. Then again your account is only a few days old. I don't wanna sound like an old geezer telling you to get off my lawn, but you should really read the guidelines for posting on HN. For the sake of genuine discussion and just better social behavior in general. Could you say this out loud to a bunch of other hackers with a straight face?

What did I say wrong? I'm just stating my plans after hearing about another security blunder on Linode's part. Did what I say come off as sarcastic?

Can you elaborate on why you think it is cheaper? It's always appeared to me that you pay a hefty premium for compute resources on AWS (at least compared to Linode).

It's probably false that "there does not exist a customer of EC2 that has been hacked", and that should be pretty obvious. Furthermore it's false for essentially all nontrivial, large services.

But here, it's not a customer that was hacked. It was linode that was hacked, and used to access a specific customer's data.

"We have been advised that law enforcement officials are aware of the intrusion into this customer’s systems." sounds like a customer was hacked, not Linode.

Then why was my password reset?

> Out of an abundance of caution, however, we have decided to implement a Linode Manager password reset. In so doing, we have immediately expired all current passwords.

In other words, better safe than sorry.

If the compromise was a brute force, then there's no need to reset my password.

If the compromise was due to a flaw in Linode's system (potentially exposing other accounts) then a global password reset makes sense.

Can you imagine if every service you used reset everyones passwords every time one of their users got brute forced? You'd do nothing but reset your passwords all day...

If a customer was hacked, why reset everyone's password? Unless there is something Linode is not telling us, there is no reason they should be doing this. Think about it like this: what if Google reset everyone's passwords whenever a gmail account got compromised? Ridiculous.

[citation needed]

Amazon AWS does have much better security for their control panel/admin stuff than most random VPS providers. Linode is particularly bad as VPSes go.

irrelevant argument at best

Reply on news.ycombinator.com