If you have left your heroku app alone for 3 years, you are definitely at risk of getting rooted: https://blog.heroku.com/archives/2013/1/11/rails_security_vu...
The thing you need to test then deploy are upgrades to your language and framework/app, and those present exactly the same problem on heroku or on say a vps. You can't just redeploy your app without testing on a new config, and deploys to heroku are no easier or harder than deploys to your own server once set up.