I never understood why do they ban water bottles but allow laptop batteries through, it's just plain ridiculous.
I never understood why do they ban water bottles but allow laptop batteries through, it's just plain ridiculous.
However, the real reason one can bring a laptop battery on a plane is because no terrorist has tried to use it yet. They would probably need multiple batteries: after the "shoe bomber" attack, the government determined that as little as 50g of PETN could bring down a plane, which is equivalent to 80+g of TNT, which is four iPad 2 batteries.
Even then, it would be necessary to deliver that energy in a very small amount of time, which may not be possible rapidly enough with lithium-ion; they can burn, but can they explode quickly enough, with all of their energy? The TSA aays they have studied the issue, and the answer is no [1], they "cannot be used as an explosive and are not a security threat in personal carry-on quantities."
[1] http://usatoday30.usatoday.com/money/industries/travel/2010-...
Explosion? Starting a fire isn't enough?
Note that the water bottle scam isn't really profiting the airlines - it's benefiting the airport operators, in collusion with many national air regulators.