Attn. John Gruber, I'll save you 3000+ words:
Shorter Tim Wu...
(1) Apple is the most successful and profitable company in the world today.
(2) Apple is one of the most closed companies in tech.
(3) Ergo closed is bad.
Shorter Tim Wu...
(1) Apple is the most successful and profitable company in the world today.
(2) Apple is one of the most closed companies in tech.
(3) Ergo closed is bad.
I'm not arguing that closed wins because Apple is successful. I'm saying Tim Wu's underlying argument is a complete non sequitur and that is more effectively exposed with 35 words than 3,500.