Some feedback:
- As some other people have mentioned, it's tough to tell exactly what is happening when you drop onto the page. You need at least some description as to what you are all about, even though it seems obvious to you.
- Have a key for all of the different icons that show up. It may seem obvious that a notebook is information about something, and a water drop is a river/stream/etc. but it won't be obvious to everyone. A followup to that is to show more information when I hover over an icon. Showing me a name when I hover over a waterdrop doesn't do me much good. Tell me it's a stream, river, lake, pond, puddle, etc. as well as its name and why I would want to know that this exists (the point of the website is to find places to do things outdoors, right?). Tell me that I can go fishing or boating on a lake. Whitewater rafting on a river with rapids. That sort of thing.
- Clicking on an icon adds a point, but it's not altogether clear as to why it does that. I would expect it to show additional information (which it apparently does in the floating pane...I'll get to that momentarily) but why do I need multiple points? And reclicking on a point does a reload of the page? Again, just make it blatantly clear why some of these actions occur.
- The floating pane. I totally get why it's there...you need some sort of window to display detailed information about all of these different icons, but let me hide/minimize or close it if I want to. The title of whatever I click on looks like it's in an input box, which makes me think I can edit it...which I can't. Make it look like a title not an input box. Additional, if I've clicked on an icon and want information on what that is, then just show me information for that point. If there isn't any, then don't show the point. You'll quickly have a bad user experience if you have lots of points with no content. (It appears that there is a user generated content aspect to this where people can input information about a point, so this may be a tough balance...maybe have a toggle to add content to the map, but hide points with no content if you're just searching) Give me the option to view other related/interesting areas in proximity to this, but don't default to that if there is no content. Also, clicking on the title of a nearby/related trip report should show more information in the pane about that trip report, not take me away from the site to somewhere else. Let the URL at the bottom do that, or have a link to the source website.
- Your homepage (the place that your Home link goes to) just goes into a continuous loading indicator when searching on my zip (21045). Are you planning on having people drop onto this page when going to Trailbehind? If not, why have it if you already have a location search on the map? If it's an About page rather than Home, then call it that, not Home.
- Eventually do some geolocation to default the map to a point close to the where the user is accessing Trailbehind from. Defaulting to a location in Ghana does not help me at all (no offense to the country of Ghana).
Anyway, there were just a few thoughts after a quick glance through the site. Congrats on getting something out there and keep iterating!