If this is a free service, how do you plan to subsidize it if it becomes popular? Will your personal data remain private? Might the site stop working at some point without warning? Will you lose your data that you've entered?
Does the site work with other sites where you've tracked your weight, like MyFitnessPal, Nike+, Calorie Count, etc, at least for the purposes of importing data?
Will there be a community element of any kind for supporting each other? Will the site let you connect to other site APIs and export your weight if you log it and track it here?