Hacker News Reader

Comment by kevinskii | Hacker News Reader

There's equity, and then there's "equity."

For example, a well-funded late stage startup recently offered me a salary that was $35k/year below the market rate, plus X hundred thousand stock options. These came with no strike price, and their grant was subject to final board approval after hiring. When I asked how I might possibly valuate these at anything other than zero dollars, they told me that this was just a standard bay area offer structure. When I persisted, they reminded me of the free lunches. When that wasn't convincing, they fell back on the old, "People don't work here for the money, they do because they want to change the world! You may just want to get rich, but we'll be happy if we can cure cancer someday."

View on HN

Even better: A year or two goes by and the Controller and CFO ignore your emails trying to get a strike price and paperwork to exercise your options. cough Perimeter or whatever your name is now: https://www.silversky.com/ cough

Add that to the list of ways to get denied your options. How do you exercise if they just ignore you?

I've got a term for what you just experienced: psychological arbitrage.

If you don't have a seat in the board room, your equity can disappear in an instant.

Grants are always subject to board approval, due to corporate structure of literally every startup I've ever heard of. It's a rubber-stamp process (for normal-sized grants, anyway) and employees always get the options.

Similarly, they can't specify the strike price because for legal reasons the strike price is set when the options are issued.

Nonetheless, options of this kind are worth a potentially huge amount of money. X00,000s of google shares, given to you subject to board approval and with an unknown strike price, would have been fabulously valuable.

However, perfectly legitimate questions:

How many outstanding shares of stock do you have on a fully-diluted basis? X00,000s of stock options is meaningless, only percentages matter. You should always ask this question.

What was the last 409a valuation for common stock? When did you get your last 409a valuation? This will determine the strike price your options get, assuming that their 409a valuation is less than a year old.

So actually, their answers were perfectly legitimate. $35k under market is quite a bit, though depending on the percentage of the company you were getting it might be fair.

> Grants are always subject to board approval...and employees always get the options.

My sibling comment offers a counterexample [1].

> X00,000s of stock options is meaningless, only percentages matter. You should always ask this question.

Exactly right. They weren't willing to answer this question in writing.

> Similarly, they can't specify the strike price because for legal reasons the strike price is set when the options are issued.

I believe it's legal to set the strike price at X percent of the stock price, which seems to be what you'd really need to try to valuate private company stock options anyway.

[1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5258483

>How many outstanding shares of stock do you have on a fully-diluted basis? X00,000s of stock options is meaningless, only percentages matter. You should always ask this question.

Bingo. I have no idea why they routinely fail to give enough information to make the option grant even remotely meaningful.

Fortunately, where I work, the head of finance told me how many shares were outstanding, fully diluted, and in writing, when I asked.

Reply on news.ycombinator.com